1MachineTool vs Ice

A free, open-source menu bar manager, or menu bar rows inside an app that replaces several of the icons.

Ice’s side read from its own site, 18 November 2026. 1MachineTool’s side checked against 1.7.0.

Short answer

Ice is free, open source and does more with the bar itself. 1MachineTool hides icons in three rows and removes the reason you had so many.

  • Both sort icons into shown, hidden and always-hidden sections and bring them back on a hover, a click or a hotkey. Both do that for free.
  • Ice also has the Ice Bar below the menu bar, a search panel, item spacing and tints, borders and shapes for the bar. 1MachineTool does not style the bar.
  • Ice's latest stable release is 0.11.12, from 29 October 2024; macOS 26 is covered by a pre-release build from 16 September 2025. 1MachineTool's menu bar module is checked on macOS 26.6.

Two ways to do the job.

1MachineTool

Menu bar & Dock works on Free: three rows (always, hover, hidden), real icons read over Accessibility, show on hover, the chevron or ⌃⌥M, notch awareness and per-display layouts. You ⌘-drag icons into rows yourself; Pro moves them for you and adds Dock presets with undo.

Ice

Jordan Baird's open-source menu bar manager (GPL-3.0), free with optional donations. Visible, hidden and always-hidden sections, show on hover, click or scroll, automatic rehide, drag-and-drop arranging, the Ice Bar for notched displays, search, item spacing (beta) and menu bar tint, shadow, border and shapes. macOS 14 or later. The latest stable release is 0.11.12 (29 October 2024), with a macOS 26 beta from 16 September 2025.

icemenubar.app

Side by side.

Feature1MachineToolIce
At a glance
PriceFree, or Pro from $29 once (one year of updates)Free and open source (GPL-3.0); donations optional
Runs onmacOS on Apple silicon and Intel, Linux on 64-bit PCs, an early Windows build (x64 and ARM); one licencemacOS 14 or later
What it coversEleven everyday tools (launcher, clipboard, windows, monitor, clean, power, battery, menu bar, network, security, VMs), plus Share Screen, Chat and Devices between your machinesMenu bar items and the bar's appearance
Tells you why the machine is slow, hot, full or drainingYes: one sentence, the evidence, the fix and an undoNo
Menu bar
Hide and reveal iconsThree rows: always, hover, hiddenThree sections: visible, hidden, always-hidden
Bringing hidden icons backHover, the chevron or ⌃⌥MHover, click, scroll or swipe, and hotkeys
Arranging iconsYour own ⌘-drag on Free; moved for you in ProDrag-and-drop interface
The notchNotch-aware, per displayThe Ice Bar shows hidden icons in a separate bar below the menu bar
Menu bar styling (tint, border, shape)NoYes
Triggers and profilesNoNot shipped; both are on its roadmap
Dock presetsWith undo (Pro)No
Releases and everything else
Releases and macOS versionsChecked on macOS 26.6Stable 0.11.12 (29 October 2024); macOS 26 through a beta of 16 September 2025; no official macOS 27 build listed
Replaces the apps behind the iconsCleaner, monitor, battery, keep-awake, clipboard, windowsNo
Open sourceNoYes (GPL-3.0)
PermissionsAccessibility, to read and move iconsWorks in a limited mode without screen recording permission
Account neededNo account for Free and ProNo
Windows and LinuxLinux on 64-bit PCs and an early Windows build now; a Pro licence works on any of themNo
InstallDirect downloadDirect download or Homebrew

Scroll the table sideways.

Which one is for you.

Choose 1MachineTool if

  • You want a tidy menu bar and fewer menu bar apps to begin with.
  • You're on macOS 26 and would rather not run a pre-release build.
  • You want the cleaner, monitor and battery tools in the same app.

Choose Ice if

  • You want a free, open-source menu bar manager and nothing else.
  • You want the Ice Bar, search or a styled menu bar.
  • You want to arrange icons by drag and drop without paying for Pro.

Questions.

Is hiding menu bar icons free in 1MachineTool?

Yes. The three rows, show on hover, the chevron and the ⌃⌥M hotkey are on Free; you ⌘-drag icons past the dividers yourself. Pro moves icons into rows for you and adds Dock presets with undo.

Does Ice work on macOS 26 and macOS 27?

Ice's latest stable release is 0.11.12, from 29 October 2024. For macOS 26 its developer published a pre-release build on 16 September 2025 that fixes most of the known issues there. No official release lists macOS 27 as of November 2026, so check the project's releases page for your version.

Is Ice really free?

Yes. Ice's site says it is free for anyone to use, and the code is open source under the GPL-3.0 licence. Donations are optional. It installs from a zip on GitHub or with Homebrew, and needs macOS 14 or later.

Keep reading.

The 1MachineTool side, in full

Ice’s column comes from its own site on 18 November 2026. Prices and plans change; if something here is out of date, tell us and we will fix it.

Report a correction

More comparisons

Everything your computer should have come with.